Kait Carson: The Cozy is Dead–Long Live the Cozy

Author photos 009On the plight of the cozy mysterySo, with all that popularity and variety, how is this subgenre under attack? Easy, traditional publishing houses, both large and small are cutting or reducing their cozy lines. Authors are being given notice that their series are not being renewed, or are being discontinued.

The Cozy is Dead – Long Live the Cozy

Genre writing is rife with pitfalls. Fashionable reads come and go with what seems like head spinning frequency. Right now, it appears that the cozy is under siege, and under siege from an unlikely source. Publishing Houses.

Cozies are not a genre. The genre is mystery in all its myriad of forms. The cozy is a subgenre of mysteries, as are traditional, historical, humorous, steampunk, noir, and the list goes on. (Who else just tapped their feet to Sonny and Cher?) A cozy can be set in the current time, past, future, even in a fictional world of fairies and wizards. What matters is the quest, and the crime. Usually murder.

What sets the cozy apart then? It’s debatable and there are as many answers as there are authors so this is a generalization. The cozy features an amateur sleuth, they are usually set in a small town, and typically, the sex and violence take place off the page. Oh yes, they usually have a tame vocabulary too. One cusses in a cozy, and curses in a thriller. Think Miss Marple.


The cozy has subgenres. Caterers and cooks are among the most popular, specialty shop owners, crafters, book club members, even soccer moms can be a cozy sleuth, and each subgenre has its devoted followers. Some of my best recipes came from Diane Mott Davidson books. If only I could figure out a way to send you a batch of Scout’s brownies! You’d see exactly what I mean.

So, with all that popularity and variety, how is this subgenre under attack? Easy, traditional publishing houses, both large and small are cutting or reducing their cozy lines. Authors are being given notice that their series are not being renewed, or are being discontinued. The last list I saw had over twenty series on it. One publishing house quote I read laid the cause at the feet of the decline in mass-market sales. Is this really about the rise of the e-book? Many of the big five publishers price their e-books in the $7 to $8 range. That seems like a lot when there are so many small press and quality independent e-books available in the $3 to $5 range. Economics figures into everything. Especially the profitability of a large press. They have a lot of mouths to feed after all and they may not be able to cut lower and keep the lights on.

There has also been speculation on blogs, but not in anything I’ve seen attributed to a publishing house, that there is a perception in publishing circles that the cozy is formulaic and the public is tiring of them. In other words, if you can dance at Arthur Murray’s, you can write a cozy. Just put your cursor in the footsteps and away you go. As an author of traditional mysteries, I can only say, “if only!” There is no cozy formula, any more than there is in any other genre. A reader enters into a contract with the author when the reader opens a book. That contract relates to certain expectations. How the author delivers those expectations makes, or breaks, the book in the reader’s eyes. If we judge by popularity, cozies have delivered on the promise.

So how does this bode well for the cozy mystery? At first glance, not at all, but writers write. That’s what we do. While we may lose some of our favorite series, those same authors will find new homes—or decide to strike out as independents. The cozy will go on. It may be changed, it may not be as available in neighborhood bookstores (the few that remain), but it’s a safe bet that the cozy will live.

Long live the cozy.

book reviews

The best way to thank an author is to write a review. Reviews count with publishers and with standings on websites such as Amazon. This opens the door to the book being a suggested read and catching the attention of other readers. 

Editor’s note: there is a lot of excellent information regarding cozy mysteries out here. I’ve included a few helpful articles below, if you’re interested. The article from Writer’s Digest is particularly insightful.

Writer’s Digest, “4 Things You Should Know About Writing a Cozy Mystery Novel”

Writing Novels That Sell, “10 Tips to Make Your #Cozy #Mystery Sell” 

Huffington Post, “The Immense Popularity of the Cozy Mysteries”



7 thoughts on “Kait Carson: The Cozy is Dead–Long Live the Cozy

  1. Good post, Kait, if a bit disheartening. I would add that the cozy isn’t the only sub genre of mysteries in peril. The original publisher of my P.I. mystery series dropped me after two books, saying they were cutting back their P.I. series to concentrate more on medical, legal, and international thrillers. I’ve checked reviews and mine hold up well if not better than some of the series they kept. Go figure.
    Regarding pricing, I continue to be astounded that the Big Guys price their ebooks so high. Examples: I have a book with Simon & Schuster/Pocket. The paperback is priced at $8.99 while the ebook is $7.99. The two mysteries I mentioned above are still being sold by my old publisher (affiliated with Random House/Penguin) for $9.99 (ebook) while the paperbacks are priced only a couple of bucks higher.
    My opinion is that most ebooks, even by my current mystery publisher, are priced too high. After the initial costs of cover and text files, I would think there is very little cost involved with ebooks.
    Wow, it must be Monday! End of rant. Enjoyed your article, and thanks for the added resources.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Well said. The editor of this blog had attached a great graphic on how the money shakes out. I removed it because it had no attribution, but the price of e-books is astounding now. I recently looked at a book I was interested in buying, the E-book and the HARDBACK were $1 apart. Too rich for my blood. Especially since the buyer does not own the book. All you are buying is a right to read it.

      I hadn’t heard that houses were cutting other lines too. I think we are going to see a lot of that because people are balking at spending trade prices for e-books. As well they should. I’ve always said I vote with my buck. I’m content to wait until the big houses put pricey books on discount, and they always seem to do it. You have to wait and catch them.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Agreed, Mike. I don’t work in the publishing business, but I cannot fathom where such “overhead” on $8, $10, and even $13 ebooks goes. Even ebooks that are $6, $5, or $4 seems inflated to me. I regularly buy ebooks, and when I do, I go straight to the Kindle Daily or Monthly Deals. I just bought Bagman by William Lashner, and it’s really good, but the only reason I purchased it for $4.95 is because I’d already bought another of his books on a daily deal and knew I liked the character. Otherwise, why would I, or any reader on a budget, want to pay such high prices? It’s a gamble I’m NOT taking on general principle.

    Here endtheth my rant.

    Thanks, Kait!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. No rant! Great points. If I’m craving a book that’s more than $5, I wait and keep checking Book Bub. Eventually, it will come around. I don’t mind high prices for hardbound, but not for something as ephemeral as an e-book.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Fascinating article, Kait! I appreciate the resources you mentioned as well since I’ve recently heard about this trend with cozies. The high e-book prices definitely deter me from purchasing e-books…I’ve always wondered why they’re so high!

    Liked by 2 people

  4. Me too, Kate. Even more true because you don’t own the book you buy, you have a license to read it. If I’m spending $8 or more, I want to have something for it. Sad, but exciting at the same time. Big changes will be coming, we just have to wait and see what they are. I think writers will be at the forefront.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. Love the article, Kait. I hadn’t heard that the big publishers are cutting cozies. When I look on Amazon I see a lot of them. I agree that the prices are too high but that’s for ebooks from publishing houses. Indie publishers set their prices more reasonably.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s